The PR Truth Test

How well do claims in institutional announcements hold up when you check the source records?

Hezron Insights traced factual claims from institutional announcements into news coverage. The audit looked for records that could substantiate each claim and examined what selected news reports disclosed about their own checks.

100 claims · 100 announcement–news pairs · 10 African countries

By Hezron Ochiel, Hezron Insights
Exploratory study.

READ THE FULL REPORT AND METHODOLOGY

What the audit found

By 14 November 2026, the audit had found documentary support for 59 of the 100 claims. For 36 claims, it could not obtain enough documentary evidence to reach a conclusion. Four fell outside what the audit could assess, and one conflicted with the underlying record.

In 44 of the 59 corroborated cases, the decisive record came from the institution that made the announcement or its corporate group. A separate document, such as an earnings table, can substantiate a figure even when the same institution produced both records.

A follow-up search found enough evidence to corroborate 16 of those 59 claims. Before that search, the audit had insufficient evidence for all 16.

Two cases from the audit

Uganda’s revenue figures

MTN Uganda’s announcement said total revenue rose 13.3% in the first half of 2025. Its earnings table showed 13.1% growth in total revenue. The 13.3% figure applied to service revenue, the measure ITWeb Africa reported.

Read the announcement · See the earnings table · Read the ITWeb Africa report

The checks Punch reported in Nigeria

When Punch reported that Dangote Refinery had cut its petrol price at the loading point to ₦835 per litre, it said its reporter had seen a pro forma invoice and checked a pricing site. The audit recorded both checks as described in the article. It could not obtain either the invoice or a dated entry from the site, so it classified the evidence for the price claim as insufficient.

How the study worked

The audit deliberately selected ten announcement–news pairs per country across Kenya, Uganda, South Africa, Ghana, Nigeria, Ethiopia, Rwanda, Tanzania, Zambia and Zimbabwe. It assessed one factual claim per pair. The announcements included press releases and financial notices dated from 1 January 2025 to 14 November 2026.

For each claim, the audit sought a separate record covering the same figure or event, period and institution. It recorded who produced the document and how it was accessed. For selected reports, it logged checks the article explicitly described. The findings apply to the cases examined.

Why the follow-up count ranges from 58 to 60

World Bank records later corroborated the approval of US$227 million in financing for two projects in Tanzania, bringing the count to 60. It falls to 59 if the inaugural Addis Ababa–Hyderabad flight requires a separate record confirming its exact departure date. It falls to 58 if the Zambia financing case also requires direct access to the register entry, which the audit could see only in a search extract.

What communications teams and newsrooms can do

When publishing a figure, name the measure and link to the table or document where readers can check it. In a financing announcement, specify whether the money was approved or disbursed. When reporting a claim, identify the record you checked if you can disclose it.